Search Articles, Case Laws ,Circulars, Notifications & Instructions

No Disallowance u/s 14A for Dividend on Stock -in-Trade : Mumbai ITAT

disallowance

In the continuing saga of disallowance u/s 14A and for the purpose of computation of disallowable amount under Rule 8D of Income Tax Rule, two recent judgments- one from Kolkata ITAT and another from Mumbai ITAT- are welcome relief for many tax payers specially those who have to bear the burnt of disallowance under section...

This content is for Monthly, annual and Semi Annual members only. Please login to view this content. (Subscribe Plans.)

Section 14A :Disallowance Can’t Exceed Expenditure Claimed !

Desction_14A

Over zealous tax authorities have many time blindly applied Rule 8D read with provision under section 14A to disallow expenditure more than actual claim by the assessee. This create a bizarre situation  where the tax department is disallowing an expense , for which assessee dis not claim any allowance. Gillette Group India (P.) Ltd. vs ACIT 12(1), New Delhi 16 ITR(TRIB.) [...]

No 14A Disallowance if Dividend Received on Stock-in-Trade

The assessee a dealer in shares and securities earned dividend income from shares. The assessee claimed expenditure on brokerage of arranging interest free loan which was for payment of conversion cost of its stock of partly paid shares into fully paid shares. The Assessing Officer disallowed this amount on the ground that it was spent [...]

If A.O Has no Power to Assess, CIT Also Can’t Invoke Remedial Power !

the Assessing Officer completed assessments without making disallowances under Section 14A even though the assessee had incurred expenditure mainly by way of interest incurred on borrowed funds diverted for investments in securities, shares etc, the income wherefrom were exempt from tax. By virtue of the prohibition contained in the proviso, the Assessing Officer was disabled [...]

14A Disallowance: 80HHC Not Exempt Income !

The assessee engaged in manufacturing and export of engineering goods. The Assessing Officer disallowed claim for bad debts under section 36(1)(vii) on ground that assessee had claimed deduction under section 80HHC and in such a situation claim for bad debts be hit by Section 14A of the Act. The CIT(A) partly upheld the claim of [...]

Section 14A:No Disallowance, if Interest Bearing Loan Not Used For Earing Exempt Income

The Assessing Officer disallowed interest on the amount of investment in shares on the ground that since dividend income was exempt from tax, section 14A was applicable. On appeal, the Commissioner (Appeals) reversed the said view and held that section 14A could not apply when the assessee had not made any claim for exemption. Tribunal [...]

No 14A Disallowance , If No Interest Bearing Fund Used For Earning Exempt Income

The assessee-company was engaged in the manufacturing of cycles and parts of two-wheelers in multiple units. It earned dividend income. The Assessing Officer disallowed certain expense under section 14A(3).The CIT (Appeals) although partly upheld the addition, the Tribunal allowed assessee fully on its finding that the entire investment had been made by the assessee out [...]

Can CIT Invoke Sec. 263 if A.O is Prohibted to Take Any Action For Assessment of Escaped Income?

The assessee claimed deduction on interest paid on borrowed funds for investment in a partnership firm where-from the assessee as partner got share income which was exempt from tax under section 10(2). The Commissioner inovoked action u/s 263 of the Income Tax Act as the claim of deduction made by the assessee and allowed by [...]