The Case
LAKSHMI SUGAR MILLS CO. LTD. VS COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX DELHI II
Case No.: C.A. No.-008932-008932 – 2013
Decided on: 10/27/2026
Diary No.: 8221/2013 ·
Supreme Court of India
The Legal Issue Before the Supreme Court
Whether the unpaid central excise duty of Rs.69,91,983/- on uncleared closing stock of processed sugar/goods can be added to the value of the closing stock and thereafter to the Assessee's taxable income, and whether the disallowance under Section 43B read with Section 145A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, is maintainable.
Facts of the Case
The Assessee manufactures crystal sugar using the vacuum pan process and produces molasses as a by-product. For Assessment Year 2005-06, it filed a return under Section 139(3) declaring a net loss of Rs.28,36,167/- and followed the standard mercantile accounting method. The Tax Auditor's Report noted excise duty leviable on closing stock of sugar and molasses at Rs.2,80,56,430/-, with an unpaid balance of Rs.69,91,983/- said to be disallowable under Section 43B. The Assessee explained that it followed the exclusive method and never debited the unpaid excise duty to its Profit & Loss Account, and that under the Central Excise Act, 1944, liability crystallises only upon removal of goods from the factory or bonded warehouse. The Assessing Officer disallowed Rs.69,91,983/- under Section 43B read with Section 145A, but the CIT (Appeals) deleted the addition and the Tribunal dismissed the Revenue's appeal. The High Court allowed the Revenue's appeal, holding that the goods were admittedly removed and therefore duty was payable.
Summary of the Decision
The Supreme Court set aside the impugned Order and allowed the Civil Appeal. It held that the High Court's premise that the goods were admittedly removed was contrary to the record, since the AO's Remand Report, the CIT (Appeals) and the Tribunal found that the stock on which no excise duty was paid or treated as payable remained in the Assessee's bonded warehouse. The AO committed a serious error of fact by disallowing Rs.69,91,983/- under Section 43B and adding it to the value of the closing stock and the Assessee's taxable income, because the Assessee followed the Standard Accounting System, had not routed the disputed entry through the Profit & Loss Account without actually paying the excise duty, Section 43B allows allowance of expenses only in the year in which the sum is paid, and the actual payment on accrual method paid beyond 31st March but before the Tax Return date is accepted. The Court observed that disallowing an amount not treated as an allowance by the Assessee is impermissible under the Act, 1961, and that the Revenue, having failed to show where and how the Assessee claimed the allowance in the books of account, ought not to disallow such amount. It found the unreported Judgment in ITA No. 4297 of 2009 nearer to the facts and circumstances of the case, considering the interplay between Sections 43B and 145A of the Act, 1961. The AO's order was held illegal and was rightly interfered with by the CIT (Appeals) and the Tribunal. Pending application(s), if any, were disposed of accordingly.
This digest is AI-generated for quick reference only and is not legal advice. Always verify against the full judgment.
